A Walk Among The Tombstones (2014) Review – A Stroll Among The Uninteresting


A Walk Among The Tombstones is written and directed by Scott Frank.  He has little experience in directing but has an extensive back catalogue in writing with credits such as The Wolverine (2013) and Minority Report (2002).  It is inspired by the novel of the same name written by Lawrence Block.

The film is set in the late 90’s in New York and features Liam Neeson as an unlicensed private detective, Matthew Scudder, who is asked by a fellow member of an Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) group to visit his brother who needs his help.  His brother, Kenny Kristo (Dan Stevens), turns out to be a drug dealer whose wife was kidnapped and killed despite him handing over $400k.

Scudder reluctantly takes on the case at the second time of asking after listening to a tape recording left by the kidnappers.  He follows the trail of evidence that leads him to connect the Kristo case to others and a run-in with the police.  An opportunity presents itself to contact the kidnappers directly and a dangerous game ensues.


I can’t excited about this film one way or the other.  This is the weakest Liam Neeson performance I can ever remember.  It is the onscreen definition of ‘dialing it in’.  His interviewing technique is apathetic at best yet delivers stunning results.  I’m sorry but I don’t believe for a second that investigating a serious crime is this easy.  At it’s worst the dialogue is straight from a trashy detective novel that I thought only existed as a joke in other films.

The film attempts to make you feel sympathy for the Scudder character with a back story that involves alcoholism and an unfortunate shooting incident.  The story employs a homeless teenager as a device for Scudder to find a path to redemption.  Sadly the young boy who I think is played by Jon Goracy (who doesn’t feature in the main credits) only succeeds in getting into the back of the kidnappers van and generally being every irritating.

The two psycho bad guys are kind of interesting and are supposed to have a real nasty edge to them but its played down in the film and every time I thought the story was going to deliver a visceral edge it pulled back.  The film attempts to up the ante by having the kidnappers take a young teenage girl but given her age and the 15 rating there is a sense the film makers were a little timid in pushing the darkness of the material.

There are sections of the film that are never explained such as the role of the police who show an interest in Scudder then back off completely.  They seem solely concerned with being painted in a bad light with regards to the kidnappings but why?  It was as if it was all far too difficult to explain so Mr Frank chose not to bother.

In an age were the cinema is so expensive this film isn’t good enough.  Keep your money in your pockets.  If you can, go and watch The Guest (2014), its a hundred times better and a lot more fun.


3 thoughts on “A Walk Among The Tombstones (2014) Review – A Stroll Among The Uninteresting

  1. Good review Barry. I didn’t mind this movie as much. In fact, I came close to loving it at certain points. Although the serial-killing villains were a bit, how do you say, boring and conventional.


  2. The chances are you want to watch this movie because of Liam Neeson, who’s popularity skyrocketed the last 4-5 years because of such movies as Taken and Taken 2.

    Well, Neeson is the only reason that this movie doesn’t suck entirely.

    In this movie he is a traumatized ex-cop who hunts down a couple of psychopath killers. The pace of the movie is pretty slow. Don’t expect Taken-like scenes in this one. No big surprises script-wise either. Pretty much standard stuff.

    The music could be more suitable for a haunted house horror film, and although there are some scenes in a cemetery the title is misleading.

    The narrative is somehow difficult to grasp. There aren’t constant flashbacks as in other movies but for the first half of the movie many viewers are confused about the timeline of some events.

    Also the movie is rather long. This simple premise could have been resolved in far less time than its 1h:54m running time.

    Check it out only if you are a hardcore Liam Neeson fan.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s